Skip to content

Cardano (ADA)Cardano communitycardano copper reserveCardano holderscardano investmentNewsproposal failtreasury proposal

Cardano Community Votes Down $5 Million Treasury Funding Request

Cardano community members overwhelmingly rejected a $5 million treasury funding request from Toto Finance to tokenize physical copper, citing significant financial risks and high management fees in a decisive vote.

Cardano Community Votes Down $5 Million Treasury Funding Request

Cardano participants decisively turned down a treasury funding request of roughly $5 million earmarked for physical copper, halting an unconventional initiative to integrate a traditional commodity asset onto the blockchain.

Put forward by Toto Finance, the funding bid asked for 22 million ADA to acquire and tokenize copper stored in warehouses through an initiative dubbed the Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve. Yet, when the voting period ended on November 15, the community showed minimal backing, with opposition votes outnumbering supportive ones by a margin exceeding 140 to 1. Consequently, Cardano’s treasury keeps the capital that would have gone toward the venture, while the outcome prompts debate over the community’s risk appetite when funding real-world asset projects.

Cardano Copper Reserve Proposal Fails by More Than 140 to 1

Toto Finance put forth its application on October 15, requesting that the Cardano treasury disburse 22 million ADA to buy, store, and tokenize physical copper.

The initiative needed endorsement from delegated representatives—known as DReps—alongside the Cardano Constitutional Committee. Moving funds from the treasury demands backing from 67% of the active voting stake. Ultimately, the outcome proved heavily adverse. DReps holding roughly 2.86 billion ADA cast votes against the measure, whereas support amounted to just 20.02 million ADA. Consequently, under 1% of the total stake participating in the vote favored the investment.

Additionally, the Constitutional Committee withheld its consent. Three out of its seven members deemed the proposal unconstitutional with their votes, while the other four abstained. Since neither governance condition was met, the initiative lapsed without any treasury assets moving to Toto Finance.

Why Cardano Holders Rejected the $5 Million Copper Investment

A variety of worries regarding financial exposure, management expenses, and the oversight of treasury capital drove the defeat of the plan.

A primary criticism centered on the investment’s reliance on two distinct asset valuations: copper and ADA. The treasury would have deployed its capital in ADA, whereas potential profits relied on the future price of physical copper. Based on Toto’s figures, copper prices would have needed to climb by about 49% for the treasury to break even on its initial outlay, assuming ADA’s fiat value stayed constant and the entire budget was utilized.

Furthermore, the plan outlined significant fees covering technology, management, execution, storage, and insurance. Toto stood to gain up to roughly 3.36 million ADA via these fees, translating to roughly 15% of the total budget requested. John MacPherson, a DRep who voted against the measure, pointed out that the treasury faced dual exposure to volatility in both copper and ADA markets. He also raised doubts regarding the compensation designated for Toto, even though he noted that the submission was fairly clear about the associated risks.

Earlier, the Cardano Foundation expressed reservations regarding the structure of the investment, highlighting specifically the heavy concentration of capital managed by the recipient and the protections that were still missing.

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from the blog