A US federal judge has acquitted two MIT graduates accused of siphoning roughly $25 million from Ethereum trading bots, concluding the government’s inaugural criminal case centered on a major maximal extractable value (MEV) exploit.
On November 16, US District Judge Jessica Clarke determined that prosecutors failed to prove the material misrepresentation necessary for a wire fraud conviction against Anton and James Peraire-Bueno. Additionally, the ruling cleared the brothers of charges related to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and money laundering.
This decision brings a close to legal proceedings that began with allegations concerning an advanced trading scheme executed in April 2023. It follows a November 2025 mistrial where the jury was unable to agree on a unanimous verdict.
Characterizing Ethereum as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” Clarke underscored the complex legal hurdles of deciding whether exploiting vulnerabilities within blockchain architecture constitutes criminal fraud.
How the Brothers Extracted $25 Million From Ethereum Trading Bots
The court’s opinion details how the brothers targeted automated trading bots that watch Ethereum’s public transaction pool, known as the mempool. These bots seek profits via maximal extractable value (MEV) by spotting chances to alter the execution sequence of transactions.
Sandwich attacks serve as a primary example of this tactic. When a bot identifies an incoming large buy order, it purchases the same token beforehand and then sells it after the victim’s trade drives up the price. Prosecutors contended that the Peraire-Bueno brothers deployed eight deceptive bait transactions in April 2023 to trigger these automated routines.
When their validator was picked to build a block, they took advantage of a flaw tied to the Ultrasound relay. The validator signed a block header featuring two zeroed-out fields, outlining a block incapable of functioning validly. Yet, the relay neglected to check those fields and exposed the underlying transactions.
The brothers then built their own block, keeping the bots’ purchases intact while swapping out the bait transactions for sales that drove prices down. By the time the bots attempted to unwind their positions, the brothers had already finished their trades.
Within a span of 12 seconds, the maneuver cost the targeted bots roughly $25 million in losses. Meanwhile, the validator operated by the brothers incurred a penalty of about 1 ETH.
Why the Judge Ruled the Ethereum MEV Operation Was Not Wire Fraud
The core question of the lawsuit hinged on whether the brothers executed a material misrepresentation relied upon by another party. Judge Clarke found that the prosecution failed to prove this critical requirement for wire fraud. She dismissed the theory that submitting transactions into Ethereum’s public mempool establishes an implied contract that those transactions will execute sequentially alongside others in a specific order.
Furthermore, the judge determined that the falsified block-header fields did not amount to fraud because the relay never actually inspected them, meaning the data had no impact on the relay’s actions.
While Clarke noted that the brothers hid their intentions and likely went against the design ethos of the relay software, she stressed that behavior that is deceitful or objectionable does not automatically qualify as criminal under the specific charges filed by the government.
Consequently, the verdict directly addresses the specific fraud accusations rather than establishing blanket legality for all forms of MEV exploitation.
$25 Million Ethereum Case Ends After 2025 Mistrial
The dismissal arrives after a November 2025 trial ended without a resolution because jurors deadlocked on the question of the brothers’ guilt. Clarke’s recent order instructs the court clerk to shut the case, halting the federal prosecution without scheduling a retrial.
The financial aftermath of the scheme remains notable as well. Court documents show that authorities successfully froze only a single wallet holding approximately $3 million of the funds, whereas the brothers had already transferred the rest by October 2023.
This ruling stands to serve as a pivotal reference point for upcoming legal battles concerning MEV, algorithmic trading systems, and the limits of criminal liability across decentralized networks. Even so, it leaves open broader debates regarding the ethics of sandwich attacks and the accountability of participants running blockchain infrastructure.
Do you think the ruling creates greater legal uncertainty around MEV trading on Ethereum? Could future prosecutors face similar challenges when pursuing cases involving sophisticated blockchain exploits?





