A group of Senate Democrats is calling on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to rescind its newest directive concerning prediction markets, contending that the federal agency is pushing operators to disregard existing state-level gambling bans and court orders.
The controversy centers on a November 5 regulatory interpretation that instructs designated contract markets to dismantle geographic restrictions within a 30-day window. This mandate could compel platforms such as Polymarket and Kalshi to make specific event contracts available nationwide, even in geographic areas where courts have explicitly ordered them to block user access.
In a November 16 correspondence, the lawmakers cautioned that the stance adopted by the CFTC clashes with tribal and state laws, potentially incentivizing companies to breach active judicial rulings.
Senate Democrats Demand CFTC Withdraw Its Geofencing Directive
Senator Adam Schiff of California spearheaded the letter, which was co-signed by eight other Democratic senators: Amy Klobuchar, Elissa Slotkin, Gary Peters, Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray, Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, and Alex Padilla. The lawmakers asserted that the CFTC’s reading of federal derivatives regulations effectively forces prediction market providers to ignore mandates imposed by courts across multiple jurisdictions.
They highlighted legal actions involving Washington, Nevada, and Michigan, alongside tribal territories in California. In each of these instances, local courts instructed platforms to halt the provision of particular prediction contracts and to enforce geofencing around the impacted regions.
The legislators characterized the agency’s guidance as irreconcilable with those judicial decisions, warning that it might prompt exchanges to offer contracts that judges have already ruled infringe upon applicable gambling statutes.
Consequently, they urged the CFTC to either rescind the interpretation or halt its rollout until the pending legal battles reach a resolution.
CFTC Chairman Mike Selig Defends Nationwide Market Access
This conflict arises from the CFTC’s viewpoint that federally supervised prediction markets ought to function under a unified national standard.
Chairman Mike Selig has maintained that platforms registered as designated contract markets fall under federal derivatives oversight, which he contends supersedes state-level efforts to classify their event contracts as forms of gambling.
Under the agency’s November 5 directive, exchanges were informed that blocking access based on user location violates federal impartial-access mandates. They were granted 30 days to either eliminate these barriers or provide justification for their inability to comply.
Conversely, the senators challenged this perspective, arguing that obtaining federal registration does not automatically invalidate state and tribal gaming laws. They additionally referenced rulings from the Ninth and Sixth Circuit Courts of Appeals that uphold the authority of states to enforce their own gambling statutes on prediction market operations.
Louisiana and Arkansas Add to Prediction Market Legal Pressure
The regulatory clash is widening as additional states contest the business models utilized by the industry.
Recently, Louisiana took action against prediction market providers when a judge permitted state authorities to pursue limitations on specific event contracts. The state Gaming Control Board has previously maintained that sports-oriented contracts and alternative event markets hosted by these platforms constitute unlawful gambling.
A temporary restraining order was issued against several entities, including Polymarket, Kalshi, Coinbase, Robinhood, Crypto.com, and Gemini. In response, the CFTC initiated its own legal proceedings to contest the state-imposed restrictions, while select companies have sought to intervene in the federal regulator’s lawsuit.
At present, the agency finds itself entangled in legal disputes with roughly a dozen states, illustrating the broad scope of the disagreement over prediction market governance.
Supreme Court Could Ultimately Decide the Regulatory Dispute
The intervention by the senators arrives at a pivotal juncture for the CFTC and its supervision of prediction markets.
Presently, the commission features only a single active commissioner, Chairman Selig, despite its statutory design for a five-member panel. The White House has put forward two nominees to fill vacancies: Matthew Rowland, a former senior adviser to a democratic commissioner, and Nathan Anonick, a Republican staffer for the Senate Agriculture Committee.
In the interim, contradictory judicial rulings may ultimately push the overarching jurisdictional question toward the United States Supreme Court. Until a more definitive legal framework takes shape, prediction market operators will likely continue navigating uncertainty regarding whether state gambling rules or federal derivatives laws govern where their contracts may be made available.
This controversy carries particular significance for platforms aspiring to penetrate mainstream financial sectors, given that unrestricted access to users spanning diverse states remains foundational to their commercial operations.
Do you think the CFTC should have exclusive authority over prediction markets, or should individual states retain the power to restrict these platforms? Could the growing legal conflict slow the expansion of Kalshi, Polymarket and other event-contract exchanges?





