Tether has pushed back against S&P Global Ratings after the rating agency kept its lowest stability score for USDT in place, citing an increasing proportion of higher-risk assets within the stablecoin’s reserves along with ongoing transparency worries.
In its newest evaluation released on November 18, S&P assigned USDT a 5 (weak) for its capability to maintain a dollar peg, which is the bottom tier of its five-point grading system. This score remains unchanged from November 2025, when the agency initially downgraded the stablecoin. Tether pushed back against the evaluation, asserting that the issue stems from S&P’s methodology rather than the makeup of its reserves. In its reply to the agency’s conclusions, the firm also brought up The Big Short, the motion picture concerning the 2008 financial crisis.
Higher-Risk Assets Account for 28% of USDT in Circulation
The latest worries from S&P focus on the shifting composition of Tether’s reserve portfolio. Based on the findings, higher-risk holdings—such as gold, Bitcoin, public equities, corporate bonds, and secured loans—made up roughly 28% of all USDT circulating as of September 30.
That percentage rose from 24% during the prior year, highlighting a growing exposure to assets subject to market volatility. S&P cautioned that a sharp drop in the worth of these holdings could render USDT undercollateralized, especially if multiple reserve components suffered simultaneous losses.
Furthermore, the company contended that the rating agency’s own history exposed flaws in mainstream financial risk evaluations. An attestation by BDO regarding Tether’s September 30 reserve figures revealed approximately $191.5 billion in assets compared to $183.5 billion in liabilities, granting the firm about $7.95 billion in excess assets.
Although S&P recognized additional vulnerabilities outlined in its evaluation, it did not reduce the score further because 5 already sits at the absolute minimum of its rating scale.
S&P Questions Tether’s Regulatory Oversight and Reserve Safeguards
The agency additionally expressed worries regarding the regulatory structure overseeing Tether within El Salvador, where the business shifted its operations in January 2025.
The nation’s National Commission of Digital Assets mandates that 70% of reserves be kept in instruments capable of liquidation within a 30-day window. Even so, S&P characterized the guidelines as overly broad, permitting assets like loans, gold, and Bitcoin to qualify despite carrying higher risk levels.
An additional worry centers on the lack of any mandate to separate reserve assets from the issuer’s remaining holdings. S&P pointed out that European and U.S. regulators typically look for stricter protections in this domain. Lacking publicly accessible details verifying asset segregation, the agency stated it could not evaluate how securely USDT reserves are shielded from broader corporate hazards.
Tether’s Audit Disclosure Remains a Point of Contention
During August 2026, KPMG delivered an unqualified opinion concerning Tether’s 2025 financials, which the firm labeled as its inaugural comprehensive independent audit. Tether framed this milestone as validation of its financial reporting practices. Conversely, S&P noted that neither the audited financial statements nor the associated auditor’s report had been released publicly, restricting its capacity to independently review the underlying data.
The agency also pointed out that Tether’s reserve statements omit the identities of the counterparties and custodians managing its assets. While certain rival stablecoin issuers issue monthly disclosures, Tether provides its attestations on a quarterly basis. Tether has previously contested evaluations from S&P. Following the 2025 downgrade, CEO Paolo Ardoino took to X to criticize the firm, stating that Tether wore the criticism proudly and citing past financial meltdowns as proof of flaws within traditional financial frameworks.
Despite keeping the lowest possible rating, S&P admitted that USDT has maintained a robust history of price stability, most notably across the preceding 12 months.
Can Tether address S&P’s concerns by improving reserve disclosures and reducing exposure to higher-risk assets? Will USDT’s established record of price stability continue to outweigh concerns about its reserve structure as the stablecoin market matures?





